site map  /  contact info   

(As published by Eric Risberg in the Business Location Guide of the San Francisco Business Times)

This tax shelter is probably one of the best kept secrets in the Internal Revenue Code.  It has been overlooked by both the general public and many professionals who are uninformed or misinformed about the potential opportunity to avoid the capital gains tax normally incurred upon the sale of real estate property.

In essence, it provides that if a piece of business or investment property is sold and another property is purchased to replace it within 6 months, then the sale/purchase can be structured to be tax-free.   In San Francisco, many properties have more than doubled in value over the past three years. Consequently, any San Francisco property owners wishing to sell their property and take advantage of this exceedingly strong market will likely face a large capital gains tax burden when they sell their property. Deferred exchanges can be a very useful tool to investors seeking a tax shelter from the capital gains associated with their current property's market value appreciation.

Tax deferred exchanges have been around since the 1920's.  In the past, individuals were limited to simultaneous exchanges.  That meant you had to find another person like yourself and exchange properties in the same closing.  Sometimes three or more people would get involved; all swapping properties with each other at the same time.  In some instances, exchanges would fall apart at the last minute and people would get stuck owning properties that they didn't want.  During the 1990's the IRS set down new guidelines which formed a new tax shelter vehicle known as deferred, or "Starker Exchanges".

In completing a delayed exchange you now have 45 days to select the replacement property which you intend to purchase, after the transfer of the relinquished property, and must acquire the new property within 180 days of the first closing.  It is also critical that you do not receive the sale proceeds from the relinquished property.  Pursuant to Section 1031 and the regulations, this cash may not be actually or constructively received by you.  One of the IRS requirements for a delayed exchange is to have an "IRS Qualified Intermediary" execute the transaction for the taxpayer.  It is very important to use a trustworthy and qualified company for this purpose. Most often the Qualified Intermediary is a representative from a title company that has been specifically trained in handling tax deferred exchanges, but may include law firms or other businesses which specialize in providing assistance in 1031 transactions.

Beyond the ability to defer or eliminate capital gains tax, 1031 exchanges can also be a key part of an investment strategy for the following reasons:

1.) Since you can defer the payment of the tax, you have more cash to invest in a replacement property.  This means you make a return on the money you would have otherwise paid in taxes and thus can increase the cash flow from your investment.  You could use it, for example to transfer your investment from non-productive bare land to cash flow rich commercial property.

2.) An exchange can be used to consolidate multiple properties into one property to ease your management burdens.   Conversely, you can convert a large property into several small properties to help you manage the recognition of gain over an extended time frame or to diversify your risk.

3.) You can also change the location of your real estate investment.  It is possible to relocate your investment across town or across the country where you may achieve a higher return on your money.   Ownership of property can be changed from an over-inflated and volatile real estate market in one city, to a more stable or higher growth market in another region of the U.S.

4.) You can defer the taxable gain of all qualifying property to an anticipated lower tax rate in the future, as is usually the case when you retire.


Tax deferred exchanging is an investment strategy that should be considered by anyone who owns investment or business-related property.  But please be aware that as with any broad-brush discussion that addresses the US Income Tax Code, the issues are much more complex and detailed than presented here. I strongly recommend that anyone considering a tax-deferred exchange seek the advice of a competent tax professional.


Broker Associate  -  415.786.3467  -  © Copyright Robin Heuer 2004 / All Rights Reserved